Thursday, June 26, 2014

Maksimovic and Phillips (2008, JF)

The Industry Life Cycle, Acquisitions and Investment: Does Firm Organization Matter?

行业周期对同行业(within-industry)并购和资金运用(capital expenditure)的影响。很显然,行业影响对于大公司(conglomerate)和单一业务的公司(single-segment)是不一样的。

在高增长行业,36%的增长来自于conglomerates,只有9%来自single-segment.

Q1: Control for the endogeneity of organizational form and financial dependence. (page 673)这话什么意思?

Q2: Growth industries - In Growth industries long-run industry shipments and the long-run number of firms are increasing. (page 674) industry shipments什么意思?

1) Conglomerates里的部门(segment)更有可能并购同行业的公司,比起single-segment firms.

2) 同行业并购跟finance dependence的关系。定义:financially dependent those business segments (single-segment firms or segments of conglomerates) that spend more than their cash from operations on capital expenditures.

控制endogeneity
2i) whether an industry segment will belong to a conglomerate firm based on industry characteristics and segment productivity
2ii) potential endogeneity between capital expenditures and realized cash flow operations: how segments respond to predicted financial dependence.

MP发现financial dependent的segment大致分为2种:
a) segments that are less productive compared to other segments in their industries。比同行业企业差的
b) very productive segments in high growth industries.高增长行业中特别牛逼的

研究结果:

第一,predicted financial dependence对于conglomerates和single-segment的收购和投资是不同的。副相关。这个好理解,对于自己现金流的依赖越大,并购可能越大(因为并购的钱没地来啊!)

Q3: 在增城和稳健型行业中. In growth and consolidating industries, conglomerate firms have a positive offsetting effect on acquisitions.这话什么意思?
。
Q4: Conglomerate会不会去收购一个和现有的segment都完全不相关的一个new segment,跟financial dependence或者其他有什么关系?为什么MP要执着于within-industry?

第二,The effects of firm organization on reducing financial dependence in Growth industries are concentrated in conglomerate firms' most productive segments. 

绕口令一样的:

  • 大公司最高效的部门(most productive segments),financial dependence对收购的影响很小。
  • 高增长行业中(growth industries),大公司的收购概率会高,if the conglomerate also has a less-productive main division in declining industry. (莫名其妙的结论,但好像也有点道理。因为主页不行了嘛,所以要并购。)
  • The benefit of internal capital market在高增长行业(growth ind.)的conglomerate中最高,因为reallocating assets的价值是最高的。
  • 以上发现和Stein (1997), MP(2002)相符
  • 与inefficient expansion之类的理论不符

第三, 不同行业分类中,the effect of organizational form on plant birth and exit很不一样。

Plant birth:
增长型行业中(growth ind),financial deficit限制了single-segment开新店,conglomerate受到的限制相对少一点。但在declining industry中,没有看到类似的effect.

Plant exit:
在declining ind中,conglomerate不受predicted financial deficit影响。在growth ind中,predicted financial dependence和plant exit对于conglomerate和single-segment的影响类似。

I. Industry Conditions and Firm Organization
Growth / Consolidating / Declining / Technological Change

AHA!: Organizational form = Organizational structure (公司结构到底是single-segment还是conglomerate)

H1: The effects of conglomerate status on mitigating the effects of financial dependence are greater in growing industries. 

  • The effects of conglomerate status should be stronger in growing industries. (因为增长型行业的大公司头头,每天考虑的问题是increasing capacity。而其他行业则在担心怎么合理的shrink operations。)
  • 增长型行业中的大公司的价值(value)来自于intangible, growth opportunities
  • 所以这样的公司最容易有agency and asymmetry information costs when obtaining external finance(谁知道你的那些新项目真的假的呀?)
  • 因此,internal capital markets在growth industry的大企业中最有价值
H2: The effects of conglomerate status on mitigating the effects of financial dependence are greater in growing industries when conglomerate firms have productive segments in growing industries and other large divisions in declining industries.

  • 如果其他segment营生惨淡,那么segment in growth ind不是可以挪用更多的钱来了吗
H3: The effects of organizational form and financial dependence are greater for acquisitions than for capital expenditures.

  • Acquisitions 比 capital expenditure需要更多的特殊技能,所以他们对于企业形态(conglomerate or single-segment)和financial dependence不同的公司,影响是不同的。
H4: Acquisitions by conglomerate firms result in increases in productivity of acquired segments. The increase in productivity are greatest in growth industries.

  • 因为productive segment拿到的资金多(from less productive segment in declining ind),他们的productivity当然应该增加啦。


No comments:

Post a Comment