Showing posts with label Alliances. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alliances. Show all posts

Friday, July 4, 2014

Villalonga and McGahan (2005, SMJ)

THE CHOICE AMONG ACQUISITIONS, ALLIANCES, AND DIVESTITURES

Abstract

The paper investigates how firms choose among acquisitions, alliances, and divestitures. @文章研究公司在这几种restructuring中怎么选择。

9276 deals announced and completed by 86 members of the Fortune 100 in 1990s

Our findings support explanation based on resources, transaction costs, internalization, organizational leanings, social embeddedness, asymmetric information, and real options, as suggest that these theories are highly related to complementary.

@文章支持的观点包括:resources, transaction costs, internalization, organizational leanings, social embeddedness, asymmetric information, and real options, 

We find less consistent support for theories based on agency costs and asset indivisibility.

@文章不支持的观点包括:agency costs and asset indivisibility.

这些公司特性部分解释了,为什么公司会选择并购,联盟,分拆的战略。

The choice to organize a particular transaction as an alliance instead of as a divestiture is analogous to the choice between an alliance and an acquisition. @比如说,两公司想寻求合作,对于一个公司来说,在并购和alliance之间做选择,就等于,对另外一个公司来说,在分拆和alliance之间做选择.

三种文献类型:

(1) 某种特定行业的选择specific industry
(2) acquisition和alliance之间的选择
(3) examine joint decisions by two or more firms to ally and/to merge


  • 研究make or buy的文章很多,但是眼睛selling vs. buying or making的很少(原因不详)
  • from a transnational perspective, both divestitures and acquisitions represent reactions to changes in the transaction costs created by specialized assets (Q: 说真的,这个不太懂!!!)
  • From the perspective of the firm, divestitures and alliances are alternative ways to contract boundaries, just as acquisitions and alliances are alternative ways to expand them. @还是互补选择,跟前面说的类似。
Other important literature:
  • the motives for contracting firm boundaries
  • divestitures
  • compare divestitures to acquisitions
  • a few studies examine boundary-contracting modes

THEORY AND HYPOTHESES

Focal firm attributes

Intangible resources

Theory of market entry modes are the resource-based view and transaction cost economics. (Q: resource-based view???不懂?!ANS: 下面讲的就是resource-based view.)

  • Resource-based view
  • The Penrose-Teece view of diversification posits that a firm's entry into new product markets results from excess capacity in valuable resources that may be transferable across firms but subject to market imperfections (Penrose, 1959; Teece, 1980, 1982) @公司有多余的生产力,而且这些资源可以从部门A转到部门B去生产,但是呢!又受到市场imperfection的制约!Q: 最后的这个限制条件有什么用?)
  • The internalization theory of multinational firms, while developed independently (Hymer, 1976; ,,,), makes a similar argument about the mechanism of entry into new geographic markets, and has been applied extensively in studies of foreign market entry and performance (无数paper). (Q: internalization theory什么意思?ANS: 国际化的意思嘛,讲这些企业为什么要全球扩张,因为resource过剩啊。)
这些theory讲到,intangible resources such as technological and marketing-resources 很容易被分享利用,如果公司A和公司B联盟或者并购。

Because apporpriability hazards are higher among direct competitors, these arguments are at least as likely to apply to horizontal expansion and contraction of firm boundaries as they are to diversification an internalization. (Q: apporpriability hazards是什么意思?)

H1a: The firm's technological resources are associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

H1b: The firm's marketing resources are associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.


@公司的技术(市场)资源,和公司是否acquisition, alliance, 或divestiture有关。

Ownership structure

To maximize the assets under the firm's control, the executive has an incentive to pursue acquisitions over alliances and alliances over divestitures. 

@管理层的preference: acquisition>alliance>divestiture

Two features of ownership structure:
1. larger insider ownership
2. monitoring by large blockholders such as institutions

H2a: The level of insider ownership of the firm is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

H2b: The level of blockholder ownership of the firm is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

H2c: The level of institutional ownership of the firm is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

Acquisition, alliance, and divestiture experience

  • From an organizational learning perspective, the value generated by an acquisition or alliance depends on a firm's acquisition or alliance capabilities, which firms develop through  repeated experience with these governance forms. @重组的value来源于公司以往的经验(主要指重组的经验。)没有干过这件事情?怎么靠这个赚钱呢?
  • Firms with experience with in divestitures may be more effective at managing disintegration than firms without prior experience. @有过divestiture经验的公司,divest赚的钱也比较多。
  • Allen (1998) suggests this explanation for Thermo electron's repeated success at spinning off and carving out equity in its activities. ( 注:Thermo electron是一个公司,简言之,这公司靠着两次spin off,发了不少财)
H3a: The firm's acquisition experience is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

H3b: The firm's divestiture experience is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

H3c: The firm's alliance experience is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

Prior diversification

Three theories offer predictions about the effect of a firm's prior level of diversification on its governance choices. @三种理论依据,为什么多元化的程度会影响公司结构。

第一,resources and transaction costs views suggest that corporate growth depends not only on firm resources but also on the applicability of resources across industries and on the potential for economies of scope offered by different resource combinations. 

@公司成长,不仅取决于公司有多少资源,还要靠这些资源在不同行业中的被应用程度(我自己的理解,如果该公司的每个部门都在不同行业中,而且没有什么资源可以共享,那就很糟糕!)另外,还取决于这些资源组合时的规模效应。

Coase (1972) argues that internal organizational costs are likely to be higher when there is dissimilarity between the activities of the transaction and of the firm because the lack of a precedent within the firm creates greater demands on the organization's structure.

这人觉得,如果公司各部门的生产活动都没什么关系(e.g.不在同一行业),则内部费用会很高,因为缺乏一个precedent(事先规划的意思吗???)会使得公司对于公司结构的需求有很高要求。

On the other hand, the greater the level of prior diversification, the greater the likelihood of commonalities with the activities of the transaction, and thus the greater the likelihood of integrating the activities ex post.

另一方面,如果多元化越厉害,他们生产活动的共性也应该更高,所以他们之后的整合也应该更多。

Q: 我几乎看不懂这两种对立对点的意思???!!!

ANS(晨晨的理解):一方面,可以理解为,公司有很多资源,但是运用的不一定很好,所以他们就要重组来把某些部门卖掉(比如在别人手里会更好),或者买进什么公司(因为人家有个很好的管理层)。另一方面,公司的资源也许so so,但是公司特别会运用资源,所以他们也会买卖部门。

第二,agency theory suggests diversification as a self-serving action that managers take to increase their compensation, power, or prestige, to become entrenched, or to reduce their potential risk by reducing firm risk.

@agency theory觉得公司多元化全是因为CEO的野心

Thus, one would expect a firm's level diversification to be negatively related to the equity ownership of both managers and outside blockholders. 

Support for H2a-c implies that prior diversification is also positively associated with the choice of an integrative governance form.

Q: 到底正相关,还是负相关,我都不明白了。

第三,because diversification almost always results from prior acquisitions, firm that are highly diversified are also likely to have prior acquisition experience.

@差不多所有的diversification都跟以前的并购有关。所以highly diversified公司,往往都有并购的经历。

H4a:  The firm's diversification level is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

ON THE OTHER HAND, some researchers have expressed the view that much of the corporate restructuring activity that took place during the 1980s and 1990s was aimed at reversing the diversification undertaken in earlier decades. 如果这个因素占上风,那么他们就是负相关了。

H4b:  The firm's diversification level is associated with the choice of divestitures over alliances, and alliances over acquisitions.

Attributes of the relationship between the focal firm and the target or partner firm

Industry activity of the focal firm and partner/target firm

Two theories:

  • A combination of resource-based and transaction-cost arguments suggests that greater relatedness implies a lower cost of integration.
  • 和上面差不多的一个观点:direct competition between the focal and target/partner firm enhances the need for protective (i.e., integrative) governance structures that will induce knowledge sharing among the partners
  • asymmetric information theory: joint ventures are superior to acquisitions when the costs to the acquirer of valuing the target's assets are high due to information asymmetries between the parties.@另一种信息不对称理论觉得,合资公司比全面收购要好一点,尤其在信息不对称可能挺严重的情况下
  • 还有个相关观点:spin-offs and other forms of divestiture create value because they reduce information asymmetries between the firm and the market。@spin-off增加价值,因为减少信息不对称
H5:  The relatedness between the focal firm and the target (or partner) firm is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.s.

Size Balance

Hennart's (1998) 'digestibility' theory argues that joint ventures may create value when neither of the partnering firm can 'digest' the other due to the diseconomies of scale or scope that would arise if an acquisition were to occur.

有人说,这和上面的信息不对称理论的结论矛盾啊。

还有人说,不矛盾,互补啊!假设同行业的信息不对称问题比较小,那么“消化”理论(我自己翻译的)可能就会占上风。所以本文作者用了一个proxy, size balance between the two firms, which they define as the ratio of the sales of the smaller firm to the sales of the larger firm.

H6:  The size balance between the focal firm and the target (or partner) firm is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

Prior Alliance

Social embeddedness theory suggests that two firms are more likely to engage in an alliance when they have a history of prior alliances between them.@以前合作过的公司,更有可能合作

Real option theory suggests that firms with a history of prior alliances or minority acquisitions are more likely to engage subsequently in alliances because prior alliances create valuable options. (Q: 什么是real option theory啊???)

Chi (2000) further argues that alliances also confer upon firms a valuable option to engage in a subsequent divestiture. @联盟创造了一个有价值的option,进行随后的divestiture

In addition, the literature on corporate refocusing shows that firms often divest or spin off formerly acquired divisions, which suggests that dyadic ties of an acquisition nature may also affect future governance choices. (dyadic ties好像就是alliance的意思)


H7:  The number of prior alliances balance between the focal firm and the target (or partner) firm is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.


Attributes of the transaction and of the firm

Relatedness in SIC codes between the firm and the transaction

Resource-based and transaction cost arguments

H8:  The relatedness between the focal firm and the target (or partner) firm is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

Governance specialization

Alliances experience could be spread to acquisition, then how about to divestiture? Whether are spillovers symmetric?联盟的经验,可以扩展到并购,那么是否可以拓展到拆分呢?这种经验的传播是对称的吗?

Governance specialization measures the degree to which a firm has repeatedly engaged in deals of the current type. As a result, governance specialization captures whether a firm shows evidence of pursuing a program of acquisitions, alliances, and divestitures. (Q: 还是不很明白这定义,这跟前面说的prior experience有什么大区别?)

If experience spillovers are symmetric across governance forms, then:

H9a:  The firm's governance specialization is insignificantly associated with the choice of corporate governance.

If, on the other hand, experience spillovers are asymmetric, then:

H9b:  The firm's diversification level is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

H9c:  The firm's diversification level is associated with the choice of divestitures over alliances, and alliances over acquisitions.

Recency of experience


The recency of experience - the proximity in time between the deal that is the subject of the governance choice and the last deal of the same form undertaken by the firm.

H10a:  The recency of the firm's same-form governance experience is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

H10b: The recency of the firm's same-form governance experience is associated with the choice of divestitures over alliances, and alliances over acquisitions.

@上一种同类型的重组,是什么时候。这个时间差对于公司在几种方案中选择的影响。

Q: 搞不懂为什么要把recency of experience列出来作为一个proxy,没有theory,也没有empirical evidence来支持这么一个Proxy.


Target / Partner attributes

Target/Partner firm's intangible resources


H11a: The target/partner firm's technological resources are associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

H11b: The target/partner firm's marketing resources are associated with the choice of divestitures over alliances, and alliances over acquisitions.

@但凡两个hypotheses,说明作者对于这些因素正或负相关,没什么把握。


Transaction attributes

Market transaction costs and internal organizational costs

Transaction costs theory stipulates that a firm chooses to acquire assets when the ongoing costs of conducting business in the market are higher than the costs of organizing activities within the firm.

@transaction cost理论:购买资产便宜,还是内部制造(管理)费用便宜。(自我理解:有点Make or buy的意思吧?)

two proxies for high market costs:

  • uncertainty in the relevant market (variability in profits of the target or partner firm) @市场的不确定性
  • the degree of specificity of the asset or activity being exchanged (human asset specialty: the percentage of employees in the focal firm's industry that are engineers) @资产的特殊性
H12a: The interaction between uncertainty and asset specialty is associated with the choice of acquisitions over alliances, and alliances over divestitures.

Transaction cost economies recognizes that the costs of market exchange are only relevant determinants of the optimal governance choice after netting out the costs of internal organization. 这一派理论认识到了,市场交换的成本,只有刨掉公司内部的成本后,才有意义。

H12b: The internal organization costs of integrating the target firm into the focal firm are associated with the choice of divestitures over alliances, and alliances over acquisitions.