Alternative Exit and Restructuring Strategies
Divestitures, Spin-Offs, Carve-outs, Split-Offs, and Tracking Stocks
Many corporations, particularly large, highly diversified organizations, are constantly looking for ways in which they can enhance shareholder value by changing the composition of their assets, liabilities, equity, and operations. These activities generally are referred to as restructuring strategies.
总的来说,资产重组就是为了增加股东的value.
WHY DO FIRMS EXIT BUSINESSES?
- Increasing Corporate Focus @增加Focus (Fulghieri and Sevilir, 2011, RFS)
- Underperforming Businesses @业绩不佳
- Regulatory Concerns @反垄断法
- Lack of Fit (TRW's decision to sell its commercial and consumer information)dxaww gbc g services businesses in 1997 came after years of trying to find a significant fit with its space and defense business.) @和主营业务不相关
- Tax Considerations @税务
- Worth More to Others @对别人更有价值
- Risk Reduction (Major tobacco companies have been under pressure for years to divest or spin off their food businesses because of the litigation risk associated with their tobacco subsidiaries. Altria bowed to such pressure in 2007 with the spin-off of its Kraft Food operations.) @降低风险
- Discarding Unwanted Businesses from Prior Acquisitions @卖掉之前并购的子公司
- Avoiding Conflicts with Customers (AT&T announced spin-offs in 1995 to avoid conflicts between AT&T's former equipment manufacturer and its main customers, the RBOCs.) @利益冲突
- Increasing Transparency @更透明
DIVESTITURES
Motives for Divestitures - Raise cash @主要就是为了筹钱
The Selling Process
Reactive sales occur when the parent is unexpectedly approached by a buyer, either for the entire firm or for a portion of the firm. @有点恶意收购的意思
- Proceeds to negotiated settlement
- Pursue alternative bidders
Proactive sales may be characterized as public or private solicitations. @主动希望divest
- Public sale or auction
- Private one-on-one, or private sale
Choosing the Right Selling Process
各种公开拍卖,或者拜托投资银行找个private buyer.很多文献在这个领域。
Page 576
Table 16.2 Factors Affecting Purchase Price Premiums
- Net Synergy Potential @synergy越大,premium越大
- Desire for Control @越想拿控制权,premium越大
- Growth Potential
- Information Asymmetry @Informed bidders are likely to pay lower premium.
- Target Size @越小的target,越容易买卖,premium反而更高
- Target's Eagerness to Sell @卖家越想卖,premium越低
- Run-up in Pre-announcement Target Share Price (Share price run-up causes bidders unsure of having adequate information to revalue their bids upwards.) @预备阶段的价格如果让Bidders不确定的话,premium反而会更高。
- Type of Purchase @Hostile收购比friendly transactions要付的钱多
- Leverage (Gondhalekar et al. (2004) argue that leveraged buyers are monitored closely by their lenders and are less likely to overpay. Morellec and Zhdanov (2008) find that relatively unleveraged buyers often pay more for targets.) @买家的负债越高,出的premium越低
- Customer-Supplier Relationships (In vertical mergers, buyers substantially reliant on a target that is either a customer or a supplier and that has few alternatives will be forced to pay higher premiums than otherwise. Ahern, 2012) @如果纵向关系很紧密,很少其他的替代选择,那么premium会高。
- Investors Consensus Around Target Share Price @consensus越一致,premium越低
- Industry growth prospects @发展前进越大,premium越高
COMPARING ALTERNATIVE EXIT AND RESTRUCTURING STRATEGIES
Table 16.3
CHOOSING AMONG DIVESTITURE, CARVE-OUT, AND SPIN-OFF RESTRUCTURING STRATEGIES
Parent firms that engage in divestitures often are highly diversified in largely unrelated businesses and have a desire to achieve greater focus or to raise cash. (Bergh, Johnson, and Dewitt, 2007, SMJ) @大多发生在非常diversified公司,为了focus或者筹钱
Those that use carve-out strategies usually operate businesses in related industries exhibiting some degree of synergy and have significant contractual obligations to the business and a desire to raise cash. (Jain et al., 2011, JFE; Powers, 2001, working paper) @相关领域,想得到一点synergy,契约关系紧密,还想筹钱的,一般选择carve-outs.
Evidence shows that the timing of the carve-out is influenced by when management sees its subsidiary's assets as overvalued. (Powers, 2003; Chen and Guo, 2005) @母公司觉得子公司overvalue时,倾向于carve-out.
Q: 有道理么?如果这样的话,是不是卖掉越多的控制权越好呢???
Firms engaging in spin-offs often are diversified, but less so than those that are prone to pursue divestiture strategies and have little need to raise cash. (John and Ofek, 1995; Kaplan and Weisbach, 1992) @ Spinoffs的母公司不怎么需要现金
Table 16.4
Divestitures
Table 16.3
CHOOSING AMONG DIVESTITURE, CARVE-OUT, AND SPIN-OFF RESTRUCTURING STRATEGIES
Parent firms that engage in divestitures often are highly diversified in largely unrelated businesses and have a desire to achieve greater focus or to raise cash. (Bergh, Johnson, and Dewitt, 2007, SMJ) @大多发生在非常diversified公司,为了focus或者筹钱
Those that use carve-out strategies usually operate businesses in related industries exhibiting some degree of synergy and have significant contractual obligations to the business and a desire to raise cash. (Jain et al., 2011, JFE; Powers, 2001, working paper) @相关领域,想得到一点synergy,契约关系紧密,还想筹钱的,一般选择carve-outs.
Evidence shows that the timing of the carve-out is influenced by when management sees its subsidiary's assets as overvalued. (Powers, 2003; Chen and Guo, 2005) @母公司觉得子公司overvalue时,倾向于carve-out.
Q: 有道理么?如果这样的话,是不是卖掉越多的控制权越好呢???
Firms engaging in spin-offs often are diversified, but less so than those that are prone to pursue divestiture strategies and have little need to raise cash. (John and Ofek, 1995; Kaplan and Weisbach, 1992) @ Spinoffs的母公司不怎么需要现金
Table 16.4
Divestitures
- Usually unrelated to other businesses owned by the parent
- Operating performance generally worse than the parent's performance
- Slightly underperform their peers in the year before the announcement date
- Generally sell at a lower price than carve-outs, measured by the ratio of market value to book assets
Carve-outs
- Generally more profitable and faster growing than spun-off or divested business
- Operating performance often exceeds parent's
- Usually operate in industries characterized by the high ratio of market to book ratio values
- Generally outperform peers in the year before the announcement date
Spin-offs
- Generally faster growing and more profitable than divested businesses
- Most often operate in industries related to other industries in which the parent operates
- Operating performance worse than parent's
- Slightly underperform peers
References
Restructuring through spin‐off or sell‐off: transforming information asymmetries into financial gain
DD Bergh, RA Johnson… - Strategic Management …, 2008 - Wiley Online Library
On corporate divestiture
HL Chen, RJ Guo - Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting, 2005 - Springer
Mergers, spinoffs, and employee incentives
P Fulghieri, M Sevilir - Review of Financial Studies, 2011 - Soc Financial Studies
Spinoffs, selloffs and equity carveouts: An analysis of divestiture method choice
EA Powers - Available at SSRN 257600, 2001 - papers.ssrn.com
No comments:
Post a Comment